I looked at the first series of the HBO-shnogo "Chernobyl". Well, I can tell you: Americans have yet another brilliant propaganda victory. The first full series of the Chernobyl filmed them, and, of course, shot just, it must be removed from the point of view of the interests of the United States of America.
The series is filmed very skilfully. colossal, Painstaking attention to detail, even to the little things. Even drum separators in the correct yellow painted. life. clothing. hairstyles. Architecture and geometry of the station. The story itself with films academician Legasova and suicide, a series of frames which begins. Really done a tremendous job of, Pricing details.
And then - at least by the tremendous work, that is mixed in to the desired dose of propaganda poison, distort the facts to create a proper propaganda effect, set the event as much as the black light, remove from this story all the great and heroic and replace it with meanness, carelessness and tyranny.
simple examples.
Academic Legasov, of course, I did not hide any of the film in a trash can, fear of the KGB. Some of them even directly addressed to specific specialists, eg, Demin and colleagues Sukhoruchkin, one cassette - is generally an interview with a journalist Adamovskaya. They have been transcribed, their transcripts printed, they can be read by anyone. Yes, there is the question, that part of the record was erased. It - there. But no history with the trash has not been. But what looks good, a? Soviet scientist commits suicide, unable to bear the burden of guilt, but not before telling the truth and hides it from the Soviet authorities!
plant workers after the accident did not wander in the territory, stoned like lemurs, falling into hysterics and crying bitter tears. They did a tremendous, heroic and vital work to prevent the spread of fire in the engine room and the non-proliferation of the accident at the third power. They put out a fire in the turbine hall (firefighters were engaged in roof, and only the roof). Leaked fuel oil generators. Supplanted explosive hydrogen gas with nitrogen.
This job, of course, not show. job survivors, such, how nachsmeny turbine shop Davletbaev, and the dead, such as his subordinates Novik, Perchuk, Hyles - it is not necessary to show. But plenty savored wasted effort Akimov and Toptunova, indeed erroneously water was supplied to the reactor, I am confident, it intact.
Akimov in the series shows a spineless wimp and a coward, completely suppressed the despotic Dyatlov. This is also a lie. Akimov was, certainly, courageous and strong-willed person. He made a mistake, but it was a purely scientific error. He paid dearly for its consequences. Posthumously to humiliate him - meanness.
more details. In the film, much burnt with boiling water Shashonka someone (Perevozchenko?) He throws a middle of the corridor, to help Kudryavtsev and Proskuryakov get into the reactor hall. it, of course, Lying. At first, Perevozchenko Shashonka never found. This is done by other people, they, of course, not throwing a wounded comrade in the middle of the corridor: He was taken to the medical unit, and then taken to hospital.
Moment with the fire, which raised a piece of graphite, and a few minutes later received radiation burn. the most amazing, it was a similar story. But there was not a piece of graphite, a radioactive piece of iron, samples wheel, and fire, really, minutes 10 it was busy, pulling her. And applicator burn, of course, It manifested itself in a few days.
Well extravaganza - a meeting of the city committee of Pripyat indoor plant hopper. What is it? That did not happen and this might not even be theoretically. What kind of demonic Elder, the keeper of the station (WHAT?) order to isolate the city (WHAT?).
In reality, nothing that was not. City no closed. Some of its residents began to leave him on the first night. Some of them were subsequently arrested, but not for, that left, and for that, that left while, when they had to be at the station - simply put, dezertirovali.
enchanting dialogue:
A member of the city committee: in the air glows (WHAT?)
woodpeckers: Cerenkov effect (Yes-ah?!), It occurs even at low radiation (what?!!!).
Authors, probably, They consider the audience ignorant stupid idiots incurious. What, Judging by the storm enthusiasm, they know, who they are dealing.
A wonderful scene with Sitnikov, where it is at the point of sending the machine seen reactor? Really at gunpoint: he is accompanied by some kind of soldier. Of course, nothing that was not (or else where this soldier in the list of victims, like Sitnikov?). Sitnikov went to the roof on the orders Fomina, but he went himself and quite voluntarily - he himself knew, that the best way to assess the condition of the reactor is not.
More scene with Legasov, which in the early morning calls Shcherbina and which he tries to convince the city to begin evacuation, but they say it, breakwater, your business the pig, bosses smarter. There was such a dialogue could not be. Listen on this subject at least the same film Legasova, which speaks directly: decision to evacuate was taken completely in time and correctly, but he at that time had nothing to advise corny for the reason, that did not know about the levels of radiation, nor about the state of the reactor. And do not call him any Sherbina, and the accident he had learned at the meeting of Party activists Kurchatov Institute. This point is described in detail films Legasova, as well as the time of the evacuation. The filmmakers were obviously familiar with the films (judging by the other parts) but this time deliberately distorted. Well, of course, evil scoops prefer to kill residents, so as not to escalate the panic. They always do.
By the way, as I understand it, of Legasova try to do edakogo hero whistleblower. well yes, well yes. Only now, he hanged himself, by the way, because, that his fellow scientists have just hunted for, that he too supported the official version, which many did not believe.
errors, big and small, in the film at every turn. Wherein, repeat, authors extremely accurate in details and trifles, when it's like from the point of view of ideology. Distortions arise only, when events need to dramatize. This is not negligence, conversely: smart, vile and conscious manipulation.
But we can write about it a thousand times. The whole world, and including our own fellow citizens, Chernobyl will judge it on the show. Which the, of course, we had to take the first. And that is why the fact of the film - our huge propaganda defeat and the impressive success of our enemies.
Yuri Tkachev
