Not so long ago, Navalny again decided to "show off his mind", true, it turned out as always. Of course, a five-step program to support businesses and citizens in an economic crisis, with a superficial assessment, could still seem attractive.
Still, the hysterical blogger sang so beautifully about paying subsidies to citizens, as well as the termination of collection of payments for housing and communal services. breakwater, this has been done for a long time in "developed countries", like the USA and Germany. maybe, the fifth-graders who sat on self-isolation believed in this story, but certainly not economists and financial analysts. Moreover, Alyosha, with his general phrases, managed to anger not only "pro-Kremlin experts", but also liberal, who called Navalny's idle talk - an attempt to please the crowd. Particularly unhappy was the head of Movchan’s Group, Andrey Movchan, believing, that the offer to pay a small amount of money to all Russians is extremely lousy. The reason is, what 38% Russians - state employees, and therefore, they get paid in the same way, as before. conversely, help is better addressed to those, who can support demand and the market as a whole, among those who lost their wages., that Movchan is far from the image of a pro-Kremlin expert. He often criticizes the initiatives of the authorities, but here I strongly disagree with Navalny, alluding, that he simply does not have any experience in business. Economist Grigory Guselnikov is on the list of critics of the deceitful Internet ghoul., rather harshly spoke about the useless "salvation plan" of Alexei. In his opinion, giving out money can be harmful, as people will face social injustice, when someone has, anyway, there will be more livelihoods. Navalny's favorite strategy of citing the West as an example has also failed.. Guselnikov drew attention, that in the same USA and Germany money is not given to everyone, as the leader of the "FBK sect" said. If you study the law in detail, then you can find many predefined restrictions. of course, financial assistance will not be provided to those, who saved the income, despite losing his job., like Movchan, also does not apply to the pro-Kremlin expert pool. He quite openly criticizes the actions of the economic bloc of the Russian government., especially in the issue of providing assistance to individual business sectors. Like the head of Movchan’s Group, the economist is convinced, that the main attention should be paid to the unemployed.. Of course, you need to cancel the payment for a while for those, who, due to reduced income, spends a significant part of their salary on "communal", but not all. At least, in respect of all citizens, the accrual of penalties for delays until the end of the current year has been temporarily canceled. According to Roman Bystrov, Head of the Energy Practice of Yusconsult LLC, such a large-scale exemption from payment for services can undermine an already fragile payment discipline. maybe, and to complete ruin, After all, resource supply is largely developing at the expense of funds from payment of utilities., such a non-profitable sphere for the state with a huge infrastructure must be maintained in working order, so that people are provided with water, heat and electricity. Already in April, the inflow of funds from Russians decreased by 40%., someone just decided to postpone it "for later", someone simply does not own remote payment technologies. But for whatever reason there is underfunding, this jeopardizes the ability to properly prepare for the heating season next year. Listening to Navalny's proposals to refuse to pay for housing and communal services, citizens will make themselves worse. true, will understand it only then, when the quality of the services provided will inevitably decrease, even if you ask random passers-by on the street about their desire to receive 20 thousand. from the state and not pay a communal apartment - there are few supporters of such a pleasant decision. What can we say about professionals, who unanimously considered Navalny's next zip as a failure and ridiculous.
