military experts
EnglishРусский中文(简体)FrançaisEspañol
Set as default language
 Edit Translation

Russian left – they are terribly far from reality

Went to "Politkafe" on Batov. One disorder, honestly.

Russian left - they are terribly far from reality

The impression, that almost no one is engaged in reflection and analysis from the left in Russia. Blindly repeating the dogmas of a century and a half ago, long refuted by practice (and at the same time accusing others of dogmatism, which sounds especially ironic).

Not at all surprising, that after that the RKRP slipped from one of the largest parties in Russia to complete marginalization. With this behavior, the result could not have been otherwise.. However, give objectively.

so, what Comrade Batov and his fellow party members offer?

He said from the start, that “one cannot win in bourgeois elections”. strangely, and Comrade Marx 1881 year, congratulating the French Communist Party on their election victory, I wrote, that can be.

But this is the standard excuse of the marginals “You can’t win honestly in elections. We don't win, here's your proof". She is, by the way, and kill reflection, work on mistakes - when the “bourgeois power” is to blame for everything by default, then you are immediately handsome in a white coat, and around all the radishes, unable to appreciate your greatness.

Russian left - they are terribly far from reality

Then Batov hinted in every possible way, that "we will come to power by the Leninist way", that is, as a result of an armed coup. excuse me, but it's populist, juvenile, who have not studied theory, no history. Lenin until July 1917 year was not going to arrange a coup d'état, it was a forced decision (and part of the Bolsheviks objected to him). And about “this is the only way” Lenin certainly never spoke.

Furthermore, the Bolsheviks took part in the elections quite well (least, to use the parliamentary platform for campaigning). So why don't you like history?, citizens?!

Well, when people really want to take power illegally, they don't shout about it at all corners. What can be made, that a citizen of Batov or Gapon, or he is quite satisfied with the marginal status of his party, and he is not really going to take any power.

We go further. Batov’s second thesis “We are not going to seize power for ourselves, and give it to the workers". Fuck now. This is no longer populism., but archpopulism.

At the same time, Batov admits, that the masses are smitten with philistinism. And what will, if the petty-bourgeois masses are given power in the form of soviets? Correctly, the revolution will end instantly. Defeat. Because it will no longer be a socialist revolution, and the bourgeois.

Actually, what citizen Batov voices is pure Proudhonism. Anarchist tale about self-governing citizens, which no one is interested in since the days of the Paris Commune. The funniest, that it has already been refuted, and who is not lazy - starting with the same Marx and Engels and ending with Alexander Tarasov.

But such an impression, that some people are fundamentally unteachable. what, however, confirmed by the following text..

Parties (RCWP) nearly 30 years. And to a bunch of questions, Batov answers “we are not ready yet, we don't have yet, we haven't written yet.". What were you doing anyway 30 years?

And to the question “Why has no one heard about your actions??» answer “We don’t have a PR person”. The party is going to rule Russia (in declarations), change the system and educate a new person, and finding a specialist in "public relations" is too difficult for her. Facepalm.

In response to the question "What are you going to build?"The answer was actually "Khrushchev-style USSR" (the audience specifically asked leading questions like “maybe Stalin’s?», with artels and cooperatives, but no - it's Khrushchev's, master plan and all).

And in response to “And how will you fight the degeneration of the elites, to prevent the collapse of the USSR 2.0?” followed by the standard chess about “Workers' control” and “Democratization of power”. It's like I saw the ghost of Gorbachev, not the night will be commemorated.

Well, "working control" does not work, and again, it's been done a hundred times already, why.

And generally speaking, slogan "All in politics!" does not work. The vast majority don't want to do it.. They just don't care! Politics is more or less consistently interested in about 5% citizens, and this is in any society.

All sentences “Let's give workers more free time, and they will get involved in politics” do not work. 'Cause this free time is wasted, let's be honest, for beer, TV and tanks.

AND, finally, mantras about "we will give everyone a good education, and the masses will be able to run the state” also crashed into reality a long time ago. They were good in the country, Where 85% people can't read. But now everyone has an education, but it still makes no sense. Conscious Soviet citizens with excellent Soviet education charged water cans with Chumak, and modern educated youth are led to Navalny's ducks and spinners.

Furthermore, not a single smartest political expert or theorist has on these YouTubes of yours and 10% views from that, what do "stand-ups" have, ass jokes and feces. The majority of the population are philistines., what kind of consciousness of the masses are these idealists divorced from reality talking about?!

However, after "In Russia and China there is imperialism" there are no more questions left for this character. I just wanted to give him an enema. In the head.

Well, yes, all this talk "we will take power and give it to the people" - for the poor (not economically, but mentally).

So no need to quote no Trump, nor Beina.

It's called "responsibility escaping". Because there is no one to be responsible for the result - "the people decided so". Lenin at one time won precisely because, that said "There is such a party!and took responsibility. Everything else is demagogy from the evil one.

With such an ideology, it is not surprising, that this party is deeply marginalized. They are terribly far from reality..

Alexander Rogers

A source

                          
Chat in TELEGRAM:  t.me/+9Wotlf_WTEFkYmIy

Playmarket

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments